I like it. It is good. I found it compelling and captivating. Like Mike O. though I have to ask wouldn’t that have been a better add for 2004? Bush isn’t running. Now he could use it against Edwards, Clinton, and Biden because they supported the war and he didn’t. It is the one flaw. Will it get him votes?
If he keeps making them this good, he is bound to find one that works.
BTW I am writing as an analyst not giving my opinion on the merits of the argument.